Reservation
+1 718-657-3537
Visit Us
175-63 Hillside Ave., Jamaica, NY 11432, United States
Hello dear
Welcome To Benny's Pizza
At Benny's Pizza, nestled in the heart of Jamaica, NY, we believe that great pizza tells a story—one filled with passion and flavor. Our journey began with the desire to create authentic New York-style pizzas, using only the finest ingredients. From the hearty Supreme Pizza, brimming with toppings, to our creamy White Pizza, each dish reflects our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction. Patrons rave about the rich flavors, like our Chicken BBQ slice, while the warm service elevates every dining experience. Join us at Benny's Pizza, where every bite is a slice of heaven, and customer appreciation is our greatest reward.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Cheese Pizza
US$18.25Garlic Knots
US$50.00Grilled Chicken (1 Lb)
US$16.00
Breaded Chicken (1 Lb)
US$16.00Meat Stromboli
US$7.50Vegetable Stromboli
US$7.50Tea Sandwich (Assorted)
US$100.00Assorted Hot Hors D'oeuveres
US$100.00Fruit & Cheese Platter
US$100.00 About
Benny's Pizza
Welcome to Benny's Pizza, a hidden gem located at 175-63 Hillside Ave., Jamaica, NY. If you’re craving authentic New York-style pizza, this is the place to be.
Benny's Pizza is not just about the pies; it’s a culinary experience that merges traditional Italian flavors with a warm, inviting atmosphere. Open all day, they offer a mouthwatering array of dishes that cater to every palate.
- Signature Pizza: The Margarita and Grandma pizzas have garnered rave reviews for their freshness and flavor. Customers rave about how the cheese quality hits a perfect 10/10, making each slice a delight.
- Gourmet Paninis: Don’t miss out on their Grilled Chicken Panini, artfully crafted with fresh ingredients and a unique basil pesto mayo that elevates your dining experience.
- Catering Options: Planning a special event? Benny's offers fantastic catering choices, including trays of tea sandwiches, hot hors d'oeuvres, and their famous garlic knots. There's something for everyone!
- Entrees to Savor: For those looking to indulge beyond pizza, their Chicken Alla Benny, featuring a rich blend of flavors, or the classic Chicken Marsala are sure to impress.
What sets Benny's Pizza apart is not just the food; it’s the exceptional service. Many patrons have praised the staff for their friendliness and readiness to accommodate requests, even during late hours. Reviews note the fondness for returning due to both the delicious offerings and the welcoming vibe.
If you find yourself in the Jamaica area, make sure to pay a visit to Benny's Pizza. With each dish made from high-quality ingredients and a dedication to customer satisfaction, you’ll see why it has become a beloved neighborhood treasure.
So, whether you are in the mood for a classic slice or looking to explore delectable entrees, Benny's Pizza is ready to deliver a slice of heaven right to your table. Trust us, your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I called maybe 10 mins after 8 asking for a grandma. The guy who answered was super nice and let me know that they wouldn’t be able to do a grandma (I’m guessing because of the time. It was close to closing) BUT they can instead do a margarita pizza. I agreed and was told it’ll be ready in 20. When i came and got it, it was ready and they were just as nice in person. I got home and as SOOOOON as I opened the box I smelled the pizza. It smelled delicious. First bite— I was in heaven. I don’t remember the last time I had great pizza like this. It was packed with flavor. I’m new to the neighborhood and will definitely be returning. Great service and great food! ”
“ Ripped the bag open, can't wait to eat, kinda good! I'm from Manhattan, and we have nothing like this... I really miss good pizza :( and this place has it!!! Omg My chicken BBQ slice was so fresh and yummy... will definitely come again, I wanna try their chicken penne next!! ”
“ The best plain slice pizza ive had in nyc in my past 18 years, cheese was 10/10 ”
“ hands down the greatest pizza place ever!! awesome customer service great food super patient i always try and tip super well when i have good cash. they are great and they even did a delivery for me when they were closing they are amazing people and this place deserves more recognition! ”
“ We come to N.Y. every year for business. Often we stay in an Airbnb close to Benny's. When we order from Benny's we know what we'll get. A proper NY style pizza. Very happy to have this pizza place close by. ”
“ Benny’s Best Pizza in Queens, NYC never disappoints! Their two-slice and soda deal for 9 always hits the spot. The marinara sauce is top-notch, packed with flavor and the perfect balance of tangy and savory. The father and son duo running the place provide amazing customer service—they’re always welcoming and make you feel like family. However, there’s a short Mexican guy working there who tends to be a little rude, which can throw off the experience. As for desserts, I wouldn’t recommend the tiramisu or any of the cakes—they’re icy from being frozen and way too small for the price. Stick to the pizza, and you won’t be disappointed! ”
“ When you want a real great pizza slice, this is the place to go to. Out of all my pizza places I visit, this is truly the best one. They serve the best pizza period. This is coming from a guy that ate pizza every day for 16 years straight. Till my doctor told me to stop. The best tomato sauce and the highest quality cheese and other ingredients. Everything is fresh here. You get what you pay for. Cheap pizza chains cut corners, this place doesn’t do that. Large selection of refreshments too. We’re talking 4 refrigerators filled to capacity with refreshments. I love the “ Stewards orange cream soda “ that they carry. This place is a hangout for the local cops and transit workers from the Jamaica depot . And they sponsor community athletic events And the air conditioner is ice cold and on full blast. Just remember to close the door behind you. ”
“ Great pizza and great people too. The owner and his son are the most amazing people ive met, and the hispanic guy who works behind the pizza (Dont know his name) HUGE shoutout to him, making jokes and chering up people when ordering pizza. I'd come to this place every day if i could. Best pizza in NYC by far. ”